Traditions · Indigenous forest communities
Indigenous Forest Communities: Taking Only What the Forest Can Give
Stewardship, harvest, kinship and reciprocity among the Menominee, the Ogiek and the Citizen Potawatomi, in their own published words
Why these three communities
There is no such thing as a single 'Indigenous view' of the forest. There are particular peoples, in particular forests, with their own languages, laws and histories. This chapter therefore names three communities and builds each profile, as far as possible, from sources the communities wrote or authorized: a tribal enterprise's own pages and articles by tribal foresters for the Menominee [1][2]; a community-written protocol and a peer-reviewed article co-authored by an Ogiek leader for the Ogiek [3][4]; and the published essays and interviews of an enrolled citizen for the Citizen Potawatomi Nation [5][6]. We chose them because each has a substantial public record in its own voice on the four themes of this chapter: stewardship, harvesting, kinship and reciprocity.
Eternal Light proposes that every living being radiates a share of an eternal life force, and that each action brightens or dims the actor, the recipient and the wider web. That is a metaphysical proposal of this book, not a teaching of any community in this chapter. Where we write 'Eternal Light reads this as...', we are describing an outside interpretation laid alongside the communities' own words, not a translation of them.
The Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin
The Menominee once held more than 10 million acres; in 1854 they were confined to a reservation of 235,000 acres in northeastern Wisconsin, and there they adopted 'sustained yield management to avoid forest exploitation' [1]. Today the forest is run by Menominee Tribal Enterprises (MTE), which describes its guiding question as 'What's best for the forest?' [8]. Tribal members tell the founding instruction as oral history from nineteenth-century chiefs and headmen: start with the rising sun, work toward the setting sun, and take only the mature, the sick and the fallen trees, an instruction a 1993 article co-written by Menominee forester Marshall Pecore calls 'the spiritual basis for sustained yield management' [2].
The College of Menominee Nation's Sustainable Development Institute, created by tribal leaders and 'prompted by' the Nation's long forestry history, frames sustainability as an ongoing balance among six dimensions: land and sovereignty, the natural environment (including people), institutions, technology, economics, and human perception and behavior [9][10].
MTE reports that the forest held an estimated 1.2 billion board feet of standing saw timber in 1854 and holds about 1.7 billion today, even though more than 2.25 billion board feet have been cut in between [1]. An independent comparison found Wisconsin tribal forests, including Menominee lands, to be more mature and more plant-diverse, with fewer invasive species, than nearby non-tribal forests; Menominee deer densities were 72% lower than in surrounding management units, and hemlock seedlings 5.65 times as common as on comparison national forest land [11].
The Ogiek of the Mau Forest Complex
In their Bio-Cultural Community Protocol, written through community consultations and twelve Ogiek data collectors with the Ogiek Peoples' Development Program (OPDP), the Ogiek describe themselves as hunter-gatherers of the Mau Forest Complex, Kenya's largest closed-canopy forest, numbering about 35,000 people [3]. They write that 'The word Ogiek means `caretaker of all' plants and animals' [3]. They divide their land into nine named eco-climatic zones, distinguish five kinds of honey bee, and follow a seasonal eco-calendar [3].
The Mau forest is the most crucial and wonderful resourceful zone. Mau forest like a scooped nutritionally balanced honey is a fertile land …
In 2017 the African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights found that Kenya had violated the Ogiek's rights, and that the degradation of the Mau could not be attributed to the Ogiek nor justify their eviction; in 2022 it ordered collective title and free, prior and informed consent for conservation projects on Ogiek land [12][13][4]. Implementation remains contested.
The Citizen Potawatomi Nation, through Robin Wall Kimmerer
Robin Wall Kimmerer is a botanist, a 2022 MacArthur Fellow, and, in the Nation's own newspaper, a 'Citizen Potawatomi Nation tribal member' of the Vieux and Johnson families [5]. Her book Braiding Sweetgrass [14] and later interviews set out the Honorable Harvest: never take the first, never take the last, take only what you need, and give thanks [6]. Kimmerer writes as one citizen drawing on Potawatomi and wider Anishinaabe teachings; the Nation's government has not issued these as official doctrine, and we present them as her published words.
Stewardship
For the Ogiek, stewardship was organized by clan: 'Nobody was allowed to cut down trees. Each clan was given their section or part to protect, conserve, preserve and utilize' [3]. Cutting certain tree species was taboo (giret), and the protocol credits this with protecting indigenous species [3]. For the Menominee, stewardship is written into management: MTE manages within an annual allowable cut and keeps hemlock stands that the market does not want, because, as forest manager Marshall Pecore put it, they are 'an important part of the ecology' [15][16].
At a global scale, Indigenous Peoples manage or hold tenure over at least ~38 million km² in 87 countries, about a quarter of the world's land, intersecting about 40% of terrestrial protected areas and ecologically intact landscapes [17]. Across the tropics, deforestation and degradation were lower on Indigenous Lands than on matched unprotected land in 2010–2018, broadly comparable to protected areas, and better than protected areas in Africa [18]. In Latin America, deforestation in titled Indigenous territories was 2.8, 2.5 and 2 times lower than elsewhere in Bolivia, Brazil and Colombia respectively [19]. These are observational comparisons; they show association, and they depend on secure rights.
Ogiek: the caretaker of all plants and animals
Ogiek Bio-Cultural Community Protocol (2nd ed., 2015), pp. 1–4; Claridge & Kobei, Oryx 57(3), 2023
Evidence: ModerateIndigenous forest · Ogiek people of the Mau ForestEach clan protects its own section of the forest
Ogiek Bio-Cultural Community Protocol (2015), pp. 4, 9; Claridge & Kobei, Oryx 57(3):313–324
Evidence: LimitedIndigenous forest · Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin (Menominee Tribal Enterprises)Ask what is best for the forest
Menominee Tribal Enterprises, 'Our Forest' and 'Forest Management Plan' pages; Marshall Pecore quoted in American Forests
Evidence: LimitedIndigenous forest · Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin (College of Menominee Nation Sustainable Development Institute)Sustainability as a balance that begins with land and sovereignty
Dockry, Hall, Van Lopik & Caldwell, Sustainability Science 11(1):127–138; CMN Sustainable Development Institute, 'The Menominee Theoretical Model of Sustainability'
Evidence: ModerateHarvesting
Three harvest rules sit side by side here. The Menominee: take only the mature, the sick and the fallen [2]. The Ogiek, as described in an article co-authored by OPDP director Daniel Kobei: only experienced elders make beehives from trees, and do so in a way that conserves the tree; firewood comes from dead or fallen wood [4]. Kimmerer: never take the first, never take the last, take only what you need, and give thanks [6].
The Menominee inventory record is the strongest single test of a harvest rule in this chapter: more than 150 years of commercial harvest with rising standing volume [1]. For sweetgrass, a study co-authored by Kimmerer reported that traditional harvesting did not deplete populations [20], though we could not open the full paper and treat this as limited evidence.
Take only the mature, the sick and the fallen trees
Nesper & Pecore, Cultural Survival Quarterly 17(1), 1993; Menominee Tribal Enterprises, 'History' page
Evidence: ModerateIndigenous forest · Citizen Potawatomi Nation (as written by enrolled citizen Robin Wall Kimmerer)The Honorable Harvest: never take the first, never take the last
Kimmerer, Braiding Sweetgrass (2013), chapter 'The Honorable Harvest'; Emergence Magazine interview, 21 Nov 2024
Evidence: LimitedKinship
Kimmerer describes an Indigenous understanding of 'those plants, those animals, Mother Earth, as our relatives' [6]. Writing about the Potawatomi language, she notes that 'Both nouns and verbs come in two forms, the animate and the inanimate', and proposes the English pronoun ki (plural kin) for beings of the living earth, drawn from the Potawatomi word Aakibmaadiziiwin, which her language teacher Stewart King glosses as 'a being of the earth' [21]. The Ogiek protocol speaks of land held 'as sacred, not only... an economic resource but also a social, cultural and ontological resource' [3].
Reciprocity
The Ogiek describe a partnership with a wild bird: an experienced honey hunter follows the honeyguide to a wild nest, harvests the honey 'and give[s] some to the bird', a relationship they say 'has been in existence for centuries' [3]. Kimmerer describes the gift economy as 'a circle of giving and receiving that recognizes that everybody in the circle has a gift' [6].
Honeyguide–human cooperation is documented experimentally elsewhere in Africa: among Yao honey-hunters in Mozambique's Niassa Reserve, the traditional call raised the chance of being guided from 33% to 66% and of being shown a bees' nest from 16% to 54% [22]. That study is not about the Ogiek, and it tested signaling, not whether rewarding the bird is needed.
Comparing the three
| Theme | Menominee (Wisconsin) | Ogiek (Mau Forest, Kenya) | Citizen Potawatomi (via Kimmerer) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who speaks | Menominee Tribal Enterprises; College of Menominee Nation; tribal foresters | Ogiek Peoples' Development Program; council of elders; community protocol | Enrolled citizen and botanist Robin Wall Kimmerer |
| Stewardship | Sustained yield; 'What's best for the forest?' | Clan forest sections; taboo (giret) on cutting some trees | Responsibility taught before taking |
| Harvesting | Take mature, sick and fallen trees; annual allowable cut | Elders make hives without killing trees; dead wood for fuel | Never take the first or the last; take only what you need |
| Kinship | Forest as the centre of identity and the economy | 'Caretaker of all' plants and animals | Plants and animals as relatives; grammar of animacy |
| Reciprocity | Harvest no faster than growth | Share honey with the honeyguide | Gift economy; give thanks |
| Observable evidence | Standing timber 1.2 → 1.7 billion board feet since 1854; more diverse than nearby non-tribal forests | Court found Ogiek not responsible for Mau degradation; global data link Indigenous tenure to lower deforestation | Limited harvest studies on sweetgrass; mostly not-empirical claims |
Key terms
- Sustained yield
- Honorable Harvest
Kimmerer's name for a set of Indigenous guidelines for taking from the living world: ask, never take the first or the last, take only what you need, and give thanks [6].
How Eternal Light reads these teachings
Read from outside, through Eternal Light, all three communities describe the same shape of action: a taking that leaves the giver able to give again. In the framework's terms, a harvest of mature, sick and fallen trees takes light that is already leaving a cell and leaves the radiating ones standing; a shared comb of honey returns a fraction of light to the bird that led the way; the habit of addressing plants as kin keeps the harvester's own light turned toward the forest rather than away from it. These are this book's metaphors. The Menominee, the Ogiek and the Citizen Potawatomi describe their practices in their own terms (responsibility, law, gratitude, kinship), and none of them has endorsed this reading.
Sources cited
- Menominee Tribal Enterprises. MTE History (accessed 2026)
- Nesper L, Pecore M. The Trees Will Last Forever: The Integrity of Their Forest Signifies the Menominee People's Integrity (1993)
- Ogiek community, with the Ogiek Peoples' Development Program (OPDP); preface by Daniel M. Kobei, Executive Director. Ogiek Bio-Cultural Community Protocol (BCP): Safeguarding Rights and Managing Resources to Improve Livelihoods, 2nd edition (2015)
- Claridge L, Kobei D. Protected areas, Indigenous rights and land restitution: the Ogiek judgment of the African Court of Human and Peoples' Rights and community land protection in Kenya (2023)
- Citizen Potawatomi Nation Public Information Department. Hownikan Podcast: 10 years of Braiding Sweetgrass with Dr. Robin Wall Kimmerer (2023)
- Kimmerer RW; interviewed by Vaughan-Lee E. Practical Reverence: An Interview with Robin Wall Kimmerer (2024)
- Carroll SR, Garba I, Figueroa-Rodríguez OL, Holbrook J, Lovett R, et al.. The CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance (2020)
- Menominee Tribal Enterprises. Our Forest (Menominee Forest) (accessed 2026)
- Sustainable Development Institute, College of Menominee Nation. The Menominee Theoretical Model of Sustainability (accessed 2026)
- Dockry MJ, Hall K, Van Lopik W, Caldwell CM. Sustainable development education, practice, and research: an indigenous model of sustainable development at the College of Menominee Nation, Keshena, WI, USA (2016)
- Waller DM, Reo NJ. First stewards: ecological outcomes of forest and wildlife stewardship by indigenous peoples of Wisconsin, USA (2018)
- African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights. African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights v. Republic of Kenya, Application No. 006/2012, Judgment (Merits) (2017)
- African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights. Judgment Summary: African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights v. Republic of Kenya, Application No. 006/2012, Judgment on Reparations (2022)
- Kimmerer RW. Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge, and the Teachings of Plants (2013)
- Menominee Tribal Enterprises. Forest Management Plan (accessed 2026)
- Johnson C, Johnson B. Menominee Forest Keepers (2012)
- Garnett ST, Burgess ND, Fa JE, Fernández-Llamazares Á, Molnár Z, Robinson CJ, Watson JEM, et al.. A spatial overview of the global importance of Indigenous lands for conservation (2018)
- Sze JS, Carrasco LR, Childs D, Edwards DP. Reduced deforestation and degradation in Indigenous Lands pan-tropically (2022)
- FAO and FILAC. Forest governance by indigenous and tribal peoples: An opportunity for climate action in Latin America and the Caribbean (2021)
- Shebitz DJ, Kimmerer RW. Population trends and ecological requirements of sweetgrass, Hierochloe odorata (L.) Beauv.: integration of traditional and scientific ecological knowledge (2004)
- Kimmerer RW. Speaking of Nature (2017)
- Spottiswoode CN, Begg KS, Begg CM. Reciprocal signaling in honeyguide-human mutualism (2016)