Indigenous forest communities · Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin (College of Menominee Nation Sustainable Development Institute)

Sustainability as a balance that begins with land and sovereignty

Dockry, Hall, Van Lopik & Caldwell, Sustainability Science 11(1):127–138; CMN Sustainable Development Institute, 'The Menominee Theoretical Model of Sustainability'

What the tradition teaches

What the tradition teaches

The Sustainable Development Institute's model treats sustainable development as 'maintaining the balance and reconciling the inherent tensions between the various dimensions of sustainability', six dimensions in all: land and sovereignty, the natural environment (including people), institutions, technology, economics, and human perception, activity and behavior [1][2].

Historical context

What the tradition teaches

The model originated in a 1993 project between the College of Menominee Nation and MTE, 'based off of the Menominee history of sustainable forestry' [1], and is used in courses, community planning and participatory research [2].

Original meaning and purpose

What the tradition teaches

Forest health cannot be separated from who holds the land and who governs it; each dimension changes and affects the others.

How Eternal Light interprets it

How Eternal Light interprets it

Eternal Light, reading from outside, finds here a close structural cousin of its own systems view: no cell's light is independent of the others. The framework adds a metaphysical claim the Menominee model does not make: that the balance is also a flow of life force. We note the resemblance without implying agreement.

Observable mechanism

What research supports

Forests under secure Indigenous tenure and governance will experience lower deforestation and degradation than comparable forests without such tenure.

What the research shows

What research supports

Pan-tropical matched comparisons found lower deforestation and degradation on Indigenous Lands than on unprotected lands in 2010–2018 [3]. In Latin America, deforestation in titled Indigenous territories was 2–2.8 times lower than elsewhere in Bolivia, Brazil and Colombia [4]. Indigenous lands cover over a quarter of the land surface and about 40% of protected and intact landscapes [5]. Certainty is moderate: consistent observational evidence across continents, but effects vary by region and land rights alone do not guarantee outcomes.

Exceptions, conflicts, and open questions

Sze et al. found Indigenous Lands no better than protected areas outside Africa. The model is a framework for thinking and planning, not itself an empirical claim.

Who gains or loses light

How Eternal Light interprets it

Eternal Light’s reading (a metaphysical interpretation, not an observed measurement)
ParticipantEffectWhy
Community gainSelf-governance over land and decisions
Forests gainSecure tenure associated with lower forest loss

Sources cited

  1. Sustainable Development Institute, College of Menominee Nation. The Menominee Theoretical Model of Sustainability (accessed 2026)
  2. Dockry MJ, Hall K, Van Lopik W, Caldwell CM. Sustainable development education, practice, and research: an indigenous model of sustainable development at the College of Menominee Nation, Keshena, WI, USA (2016)
  3. Sze JS, Carrasco LR, Childs D, Edwards DP. Reduced deforestation and degradation in Indigenous Lands pan-tropically (2022)
  4. FAO and FILAC. Forest governance by indigenous and tribal peoples: An opportunity for climate action in Latin America and the Caribbean (2021)
  5. Garnett ST, Burgess ND, Fa JE, Fernández-Llamazares Á, Molnár Z, Robinson CJ, Watson JEM, et al.. A spatial overview of the global importance of Indigenous lands for conservation (2018)

Related teachings