Indigenous forest communities · Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin
Take only the mature, the sick and the fallen trees
Nesper & Pecore, Cultural Survival Quarterly 17(1), 1993; Menominee Tribal Enterprises, 'History' page
What the tradition teaches
Menominee oral history attributes to nineteenth-century chiefs and headmen the instruction to 'Start with the rising sun and work toward the setting sun, but take only the mature trees, the sick trees' and the trees that have fallen [1][2]. By the time the harvest reached the far side of the forest, the first stands would be ready again.
Historical context
Confined in 1854 to 235,000 acres of a homeland that once exceeded 10 million acres, the Menominee adopted 'sustained yield management to avoid forest exploitation' [3]. A 1993 article co-written by Menominee forester Marshall Pecore records that this oral charge is regarded as 'the spiritual basis for sustained yield management', and that the sustained-yield mandate is written into the Menominee Constitution adopted in 1976 [1]. Federal termination of the tribe in 1961 interrupted tribal control; Menominee Tribal Enterprises has managed the forest since restoration [1]. Pecore later summarized the approach for professional foresters in an article titled "Menominee Sustained-Yield Management: A Successful Land Ethic in Practice" [4].
Original meaning and purpose
How Eternal Light interprets it
Eternal Light, as an outside interpretation, reads this rule as a way of taking only light that the forest is already releasing. Mature, sick and fallen trees are cells whose radiance is turning toward the soil; taking them leaves the young, strong radiators in place, so the forest's total light holds or grows. The harvester gains materially and, in the framework's metaphysical proposal, gains light by taking without diminishing the system. The community gains a forest that can provide again. This is the book's reading, not a Menominee teaching.
Observable mechanism
Harvesting at or below growth, focused on mature, declining and fallen stems, will maintain or increase standing timber volume over long periods. Testable by comparing successive forest inventories against cumulative harvest.
What the research shows
MTE reports about 1.2 billion board feet of standing saw timber in 1854 and about 1.7 billion today, after more than 2.25 billion board feet harvested [3]. Successive inventories (1963, 1970, 1979, 1989) each showed more standing timber than the last [1]. Waller & Reo found tribal forestlands in Wisconsin more mature and more diverse than comparable non-tribal forests [5]. Certainty is moderate: the record is long and consistent but comes from one forest, partly from the managing enterprise's own figures, and the 1854 baseline is an estimate.
Exceptions, conflicts, and open questions
The Menominee forest is not untouched: about 14 million board feet of saw timber and 75,000 cords of pulpwood are cut each year [6], and modern practice includes silvicultural methods (group and patch selection) beyond the literal rule. Under federal management in the early 20th century, cutting at times exceeded sustainable limits. Figures vary between sources (e.g. 2.25 vs 2.5 billion board feet harvested).
Who gains or loses light
How Eternal Light interprets it
| Participant | Effect | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Forests | ▲ gain | Standing volume maintained and increased under selective harvest |
| Community | ▲ gain | Long-term livelihood and self-sufficiency |
| Plants | ◆ mixed | Individual trees are cut; the population persists |
| Soil and land | ▲ gain | Fallen and retained wood returns to the soil (framework reading) |
Sources cited
- Nesper L, Pecore M. The Trees Will Last Forever: The Integrity of Their Forest Signifies the Menominee People's Integrity (1993)
- Johnson C, Johnson B. Menominee Forest Keepers (2012)
- Menominee Tribal Enterprises. MTE History (accessed 2026)
- Pecore M. Menominee Sustained-Yield Management: A Successful Land Ethic in Practice (1992)
- Waller DM, Reo NJ. First stewards: ecological outcomes of forest and wildlife stewardship by indigenous peoples of Wisconsin, USA (2018)
- Menominee Tribal Enterprises. Our Forest (Menominee Forest) (accessed 2026)