Indigenous forest communities · Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin (Menominee Tribal Enterprises)

Ask what is best for the forest

Menominee Tribal Enterprises, 'Our Forest' and 'Forest Management Plan' pages; Marshall Pecore quoted in American Forests

What the tradition teaches

What the tradition teaches

MTE states that the Menominee forest is managed under a 'What's best for the forest?' philosophy, across a wide range of cover types and age classes, within an annual allowable cut [1][2]. Forest manager Marshall Pecore: 'We maintain stands of hemlock, which is not desirable in the marketplace, but is an important part of the ecology' [3].

Historical context

What the tradition teaches

MTE describes its mission as balancing forest health with the needs of employees, customers, the tribal community and future generations [1]. Pecore: 'If we keep a lot of diversity — species diversity, vegetation diversity — then we'll have a healthy ecological forest' [3].

Original meaning and purpose

What the tradition teaches

The forest's needs come first, and the economy is shaped to fit them, rather than the reverse.

How Eternal Light interprets it

How Eternal Light interprets it

Eternal Light, as an outside reading, sees this question as a turning of attention from the harvester's cell to the whole system. Keeping a commercially worthless hemlock stand costs income but, in the framework's proposal, keeps more radiating cells (trees, the animals they shelter, the soil beneath) alive and bright. The decision-maker gains light by acting for the system rather than for the self. This reading is the book's, not the Menominee's.

Observable mechanism

What research supports

Forests managed for diversity and maturity, with hunting that keeps deer densities low, will show higher plant diversity, better regeneration of browse-sensitive trees and fewer invasive species than comparable nearby forests.

What the research shows

What research supports

MTE states the Menominee forest has higher tree-species diversity than forests to its north or south [1]. Waller & Reo found tribal forestlands in Wisconsin had more plant diversity and fewer invasive species than nearby non-tribal lands; Menominee deer densities were 72% lower than surrounding units, and Menominee lands had 5.65 times as many hemlock seedlings as comparison national forests [4]. Evidence is limited: observational, regional, and unable to separate management philosophy from hunting, history and land tenure.

Exceptions, conflicts, and open questions

Some of the diversity comparisons in Waller & Reo come from Ojibwe reservations, not Menominee lands. A 'forest first' philosophy still involves commercial logging and active silviculture.

Who gains or loses light

How Eternal Light interprets it

Eternal Light’s reading (a metaphysical interpretation, not an observed measurement)
ParticipantEffectWhy
Forests gainDiverse, structurally complex forest retained
Plants gainLow-value species such as hemlock retained
Animals gainHabitat diversity; lower deer browse pressure
Community mixedShort-term income forgone for long-term forest health

Sources cited

  1. Menominee Tribal Enterprises. Our Forest (Menominee Forest) (accessed 2026)
  2. Menominee Tribal Enterprises. Forest Management Plan (accessed 2026)
  3. Johnson C, Johnson B. Menominee Forest Keepers (2012)
  4. Waller DM, Reo NJ. First stewards: ecological outcomes of forest and wildlife stewardship by indigenous peoples of Wisconsin, USA (2018)

Related teachings