Action chain 2 of 10

Planting a tree

A person plants a native tree seedling and tends it

The framework's clearest picture of shared gain: tree and planter both gain light, and the benefit spreads over decades. Research supports parts of that picture — native forests deliver more biodiversity and erosion control than plantations, and time in green places is associated with wellbeing — but also shows that many planted trees die and that species and placement decide whether planting helps or harms [1] [2] [3].

3D scene · Action trace

Tracing an action: Planting a tree

Conceptual pathway (Eternal Light proposal) Observed pathway (empirical support)▲ gain · ▼ loss · ◆ mixed
Diagram: Planting a tree. 8 pathways from the actor to recipients and the wider system.ACTORRECIPIENTWIDER SYSTEMThe planterThe treeSoilAtmosphereWildlifeNeighbours

Direct effects

  1. The planter → The tree: Light given in care; the tree's own light grows (The tree gains light)Conceptual Not empirical
  2. The planter → The tree: Survival is not assured: mean mortality 18% at 1 year and 44% at 5 years in Asian restoration plantings (The tree mixed effect)Observed Moderate [source][source]

Downstream effects

  1. The tree → Soil: Native forest cover controls soil erosion better than plantations (Soil gains light)Observed Moderate [source]
  2. The tree → Atmosphere: Growing biomass stores carbon drawn from the atmosphere (Atmosphere gains light)Observed Moderate [source][source]
  3. The tree → Wildlife: Biodiversity gain depends on native species; introduced forestry trees can become invasive (Wildlife mixed effect)Observed Moderate [source][source]
  4. The tree → Neighbours: Urban green space is associated with lower mortality and better mood (Neighbours gains light)Observed Limited [source]

Feedback

  1. Neighbours → The planter: Two hours a week in nature is associated with better self-reported health and wellbeing (The planter gains light)Observed Limited [source]
  2. The tree → The planter: Light returned to the planter across the tree's lifetime (The planter gains light)Conceptual Not empirical

What changes the outcome

Species. Native species deliver more biodiversity than plantations or exotics [2]; some forestry trees become invasive [4].

Placement. Planting in grasslands or on land that would regenerate naturally can cause harm [3].

Aftercare. Survival depends on site and care; few organisations even report it [5] [1].

Local ownership. Projects that serve local needs and involve local people tend to last [6].

Time horizon. Most benefits arrive over decades — the framework's light accrues slowly, as in Ḥoni's carob tree [7].

Sources cited

  1. Banin LF, Raine EH, Rowland LM, Chazdon RL, et al. (40 authors). The road to recovery: a synthesis of outcomes from ecosystem restoration in tropical and sub-tropical Asian forests (2023 (online 2022))
  2. Hua F, Bruijnzeel LA, Meli P, Martin PA, et al.. The biodiversity and ecosystem service contributions and trade-offs of forest restoration approaches (2022)
  3. Holl KD, Brancalion PHS. Tree planting is not a simple solution (2020)
  4. Richardson DM. Forestry Trees as Invasive Aliens (1998)
  5. Martin MP, Woodbury DJ, Doroski DA, Nagele E, Storace M, Cook-Patton SC, Pasternack R, Ashton MS. People plant trees for utility more often than for biodiversity or carbon (2021)
  6. Brancalion PHS, Holl KD. Guidance for successful tree planting initiatives (2020)
  7. Sefaria. Sefaria: A Living Library of Jewish Texts (2024)